taler-rust

GNU Taler code in Rust. Largely core banking integrations.
Log | Files | Refs | Submodules | README | LICENSE

subject.rs (21765B)


      1 /*
      2   This file is part of TALER
      3   Copyright (C) 2024-2026 Taler Systems SA
      4 
      5   TALER is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the
      6   terms of the GNU Affero General Public License as published by the Free Software
      7   Foundation; either version 3, or (at your option) any later version.
      8 
      9   TALER is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY
     10   WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR
     11   A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU Affero General Public License for more details.
     12 
     13   You should have received a copy of the GNU Affero General Public License along with
     14   TALER; see the file COPYING.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>
     15 */
     16 
     17 use std::{
     18     fmt::{Debug, Display, Write as _},
     19     str::FromStr,
     20 };
     21 
     22 use aws_lc_rs::digest::{SHA256, digest};
     23 use compact_str::CompactString;
     24 use taler_common::{
     25     api::{EddsaPublicKey, ShortHashCode},
     26     db::IncomingType,
     27     encoding::base32::{Base32Error, CROCKFORD_ALPHABET},
     28     types::url,
     29 };
     30 use url::Url;
     31 
     32 #[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]
     33 pub enum IncomingSubject {
     34     Key(IncomingKey),
     35     AdminBalanceAdjust,
     36 }
     37 
     38 #[derive(Debug, Clone, PartialEq, Eq)]
     39 pub struct IncomingKey {
     40     pub ty: IncomingType,
     41     pub key: EddsaPublicKey,
     42 }
     43 
     44 impl IncomingKey {
     45     pub fn reserve(key: EddsaPublicKey) -> Self {
     46         Self {
     47             ty: IncomingType::reserve,
     48             key,
     49         }
     50     }
     51 
     52     pub fn kyc(key: EddsaPublicKey) -> Self {
     53         Self {
     54             ty: IncomingType::kyc,
     55             key,
     56         }
     57     }
     58 
     59     pub fn map(key: EddsaPublicKey) -> Self {
     60         Self {
     61             ty: IncomingType::map,
     62             key,
     63         }
     64     }
     65 }
     66 
     67 #[derive(Debug, PartialEq, Eq)]
     68 pub struct OutgoingSubject {
     69     pub wtid: ShortHashCode,
     70     pub exchange_base_url: Url,
     71     pub metadata: Option<CompactString>,
     72 }
     73 
     74 impl OutgoingSubject {
     75     /// Generate a random outgoing subject for https://exchange.test.com
     76     pub fn rand() -> Self {
     77         Self {
     78             wtid: ShortHashCode::rand(),
     79             exchange_base_url: url("https://exchange.test.com"),
     80             metadata: None,
     81         }
     82     }
     83 }
     84 
     85 /** Base32 quality by proximity to spec and error probability */
     86 #[derive(Debug, Clone, Copy, PartialEq, Eq, PartialOrd, Ord)]
     87 enum Base32Quality {
     88     /// Both mixed casing and mixed characters, that's weird
     89     Mixed,
     90     /// Standard but use lowercase, maybe the client shown lowercase in the UI
     91     Standard,
     92     /// Uppercase but mixed characters, its common when making typos
     93     Upper,
     94     /// Both uppercase and use the standard alphabet as it should
     95     UpperStandard,
     96 }
     97 
     98 impl Base32Quality {
     99     pub fn measure(s: &str) -> Self {
    100         let mut uppercase = true;
    101         let mut standard = true;
    102         for b in s.bytes() {
    103             uppercase &= b.is_ascii_uppercase() | b.is_ascii_digit();
    104             standard &= CROCKFORD_ALPHABET.contains(&b)
    105                 | CROCKFORD_ALPHABET.contains(&b.to_ascii_uppercase())
    106         }
    107         match (uppercase, standard) {
    108             (true, true) => Base32Quality::UpperStandard,
    109             (true, false) => Base32Quality::Upper,
    110             (false, true) => Base32Quality::Standard,
    111             (false, false) => Base32Quality::Mixed,
    112         }
    113     }
    114 }
    115 
    116 #[derive(Debug)]
    117 pub struct Candidate {
    118     subject: IncomingSubject,
    119     quality: Base32Quality,
    120 }
    121 
    122 #[derive(Debug, PartialEq, Eq)]
    123 pub enum IncomingSubjectResult {
    124     Success(IncomingSubject),
    125     Ambiguous,
    126 }
    127 
    128 #[derive(Debug, PartialEq, Eq, thiserror::Error)]
    129 pub enum IncomingSubjectErr {
    130     #[error("found multiple public keys")]
    131     Ambiguous,
    132     #[error("missing reserve public key")]
    133     Missing,
    134 }
    135 
    136 #[derive(Debug, thiserror::Error)]
    137 pub enum OutgoingSubjectErr {
    138     #[error("missing parts")]
    139     MissingParts,
    140     #[error("malformed wtid: {0}")]
    141     Wtid(#[from] Base32Error<32>),
    142     #[error("malformed exchange url: {0}")]
    143     Url(#[from] url::ParseError),
    144 }
    145 
    146 /// Parse a talerable outgoing transfer subject
    147 pub fn parse_outgoing(subject: &str) -> Result<OutgoingSubject, OutgoingSubjectErr> {
    148     let mut parts = subject.split(' ');
    149     let first = parts.next().ok_or(OutgoingSubjectErr::MissingParts)?;
    150     let second = parts.next().ok_or(OutgoingSubjectErr::MissingParts)?;
    151     Ok(if let Some(third) = parts.next() {
    152         OutgoingSubject {
    153             wtid: second.parse()?,
    154             exchange_base_url: third.parse()?,
    155             metadata: Some(first.into()),
    156         }
    157     } else {
    158         OutgoingSubject {
    159             wtid: first.parse()?,
    160             exchange_base_url: second.parse()?,
    161             metadata: None,
    162         }
    163     })
    164 }
    165 
    166 /// Format an outgoing subject
    167 pub fn fmt_out_subject(
    168     wtid: &ShortHashCode,
    169     url: impl AsRef<str>,
    170     metadata: Option<&str>,
    171 ) -> String {
    172     let mut buf = String::new();
    173     if let Some(metadata) = metadata {
    174         buf.push_str(metadata);
    175         buf.push(' ');
    176     }
    177     write!(&mut buf, "{wtid} {}", url.as_ref()).unwrap();
    178     buf
    179 }
    180 
    181 /// Format an incoming subject
    182 pub fn fmt_in_subject(ty: IncomingType, key: &EddsaPublicKey) -> impl Display {
    183     std::fmt::from_fn(move |f| match ty {
    184         IncomingType::reserve => write!(f, "{key}"),
    185         IncomingType::kyc => write!(f, "KYC:{key}"),
    186         IncomingType::map => write!(f, "MAP:{key}"),
    187     })
    188 }
    189 
    190 /**
    191  * Extract the public key from an unstructured incoming transfer subject.
    192  *
    193  * When a user enters the transfer object in an unstructured way, for ex in
    194  * their banking UI, they may mistakenly enter separators such as ' \n-+' and
    195  * make typos.
    196  * To parse them while ignoring user errors, we reconstruct valid keys from key
    197  * parts, resolving ambiguities where possible.
    198  **/
    199 pub fn parse_incoming_unstructured(subject: &str) -> Result<IncomingSubject, IncomingSubjectErr> {
    200     // We expect subject to be less than 65KB
    201     assert!(subject.len() <= u16::MAX as usize);
    202 
    203     const KEY_SIZE: usize = 52;
    204     const PREFIXED_SIZE: usize = KEY_SIZE + 3;
    205     const ADMIN_BALANCE_ADJUST: &str = "ADMINBALANCEADJUST";
    206 
    207     /** Parse an incoming subject */
    208     #[inline]
    209     fn parse_single(str: &str) -> Option<Candidate> {
    210         if str == ADMIN_BALANCE_ADJUST {
    211             return Some(Candidate {
    212                 subject: IncomingSubject::AdminBalanceAdjust,
    213                 quality: Base32Quality::UpperStandard,
    214             });
    215         }
    216         // Check key type
    217         let (ty, raw) = match str.len() {
    218             KEY_SIZE => (IncomingType::reserve, str),
    219             PREFIXED_SIZE => {
    220                 if let Some(key) = str.strip_prefix("KYC") {
    221                     (IncomingType::kyc, key)
    222                 } else if let Some(key) = str.strip_prefix("MAP") {
    223                     (IncomingType::map, key)
    224                 } else {
    225                     return None;
    226                 }
    227             }
    228             _ => return None,
    229         };
    230 
    231         // Check key validity
    232         let key = EddsaPublicKey::from_str(raw).ok()?;
    233 
    234         let quality = Base32Quality::measure(raw);
    235         Some(Candidate {
    236             subject: IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey { ty, key }),
    237             quality,
    238         })
    239     }
    240 
    241     // Find and concatenate valid parts of a keys
    242     let (parts, concatenated) = {
    243         let mut parts = Vec::with_capacity(4);
    244         let mut concatenated = String::with_capacity(subject.len().min(PREFIXED_SIZE + 10));
    245         parts.push(0u16);
    246         for part in subject.as_bytes().split(|b| !b.is_ascii_alphanumeric()) {
    247             // SAFETY: part are all valid ASCII alphanumeric
    248             concatenated.push_str(unsafe { std::str::from_utf8_unchecked(part) });
    249             parts.push(concatenated.len() as u16);
    250         }
    251         (parts, concatenated)
    252     };
    253 
    254     // Find best candidates
    255     let mut best: Option<(IncomingType, EddsaPublicKey, Base32Quality)> = None;
    256     // For each part as a starting point
    257     for (i, &start) in parts.iter().enumerate() {
    258         // Use progressively longer concatenation
    259         for &end in parts[i..].iter().skip(1) {
    260             let len = (end - start) as usize;
    261             // Until they are to long to be a key
    262             if len > PREFIXED_SIZE {
    263                 break;
    264             } else if len != KEY_SIZE && len != PREFIXED_SIZE && len != ADMIN_BALANCE_ADJUST.len() {
    265                 continue;
    266             }
    267 
    268             // Parse the concatenated parts
    269             // SAFETY: we now end.end <= concatenated.len
    270             let slice = unsafe { &concatenated.get_unchecked(start as usize..end as usize) };
    271             if let Some(new) = parse_single(slice) {
    272                 let (nty, nkey) = match new.subject {
    273                     IncomingSubject::AdminBalanceAdjust => {
    274                         return Ok(IncomingSubject::AdminBalanceAdjust);
    275                     }
    276                     IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey { ty, key }) => (ty, key),
    277                 };
    278                 // On success update best candidate
    279                 match best {
    280                     Some((bty, bkey, bquality)) => {
    281                         if new.quality > bquality // We prefer high quality keys
    282                                 || matches!( // We prefer prefixed keys over reserve keys
    283                                     (bty, nty),
    284                                     (IncomingType::reserve, IncomingType::kyc | IncomingType::map)
    285                                 )
    286                         {
    287                             best = Some((nty, nkey, new.quality))
    288                         } else if bkey != nkey // If keys are different
    289                                 && bquality == new.quality // Of same quality
    290                                 && !matches!( // And prefixing is different
    291                                     (bty, nty),
    292                                     (IncomingType::kyc | IncomingType::map, IncomingType::reserve)
    293                                 )
    294                         {
    295                             return Err(IncomingSubjectErr::Ambiguous);
    296                         }
    297                     }
    298                     None => best = Some((nty, nkey, new.quality)),
    299                 }
    300             }
    301         }
    302     }
    303 
    304     if let Some((ty, key, _)) = best {
    305         Ok(IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey { ty, key }))
    306     } else {
    307         Err(IncomingSubjectErr::Missing)
    308     }
    309 }
    310 
    311 // Modulo 10 Recursive
    312 fn mod10_recursive(bytes: &[u8]) -> u8 {
    313     const LOOKUP_TABLE: [u8; 10] = [0, 9, 4, 6, 8, 2, 7, 1, 3, 5];
    314     // Modulo 10 Recursive calculation
    315     let mut carry = 0u8;
    316     for &b in bytes {
    317         // ASCII '0'-'9' is 0x30-0x39. Subtracting b'0' (48) gives the integer.
    318         let digit = b - b'0';
    319         carry = LOOKUP_TABLE[((carry + digit) % 10) as usize];
    320     }
    321     carry
    322 }
    323 
    324 /// Encode a public key as a QR-Bill reference
    325 pub fn subject_fmt_qr_bill(key_bytes: &[u8]) -> String {
    326     // High-Entropy Hash (SHA-256) to ensure even distribution
    327     let hash = digest(&SHA256, key_bytes);
    328 
    329     // Compute hash % 10^26
    330     let hash_mod = hash.as_ref().chunks(3).fold(0u128, |rem, chunk| {
    331         chunk.iter().fold(rem, |r, &b| r * 256 + b as u128) % 10u128.pow(26)
    332     });
    333 
    334     // Format to 26 digits with leading zeros
    335     let reference_base = format!("{:0>26}", hash_mod);
    336 
    337     // Modulo 10 Recursive calculation
    338     let carry = mod10_recursive(reference_base.as_bytes());
    339     let checksum = (10 - carry) % 10;
    340 
    341     // Combine base (26) + checksum (1) = 27 characters
    342     format!("{}{}", reference_base, checksum)
    343 }
    344 
    345 /// Check if a string is a valid QR-Bill reference
    346 pub fn subject_is_qr_bill(reference: &str) -> bool {
    347     // Quick length and numeric check
    348     if reference.len() != 27 || !reference.chars().all(|c| c.is_ascii_digit()) {
    349         return false;
    350     }
    351 
    352     // If the check digit is correct, the final carry will be 0
    353     mod10_recursive(reference.as_bytes()) == 0
    354 }
    355 
    356 #[cfg(test)]
    357 mod test {
    358     use std::str::FromStr as _;
    359 
    360     use taler_common::{
    361         api::{EddsaPublicKey, ShortHashCode},
    362         db::IncomingType,
    363         types::url,
    364     };
    365 
    366     use crate::subject::{
    367         Base32Quality, IncomingKey, IncomingSubject, IncomingSubjectErr, OutgoingSubject,
    368         fmt_out_subject, mod10_recursive, parse_incoming_unstructured, parse_outgoing,
    369         subject_fmt_qr_bill, subject_is_qr_bill,
    370     };
    371 
    372     #[test]
    373     fn qrbill() {
    374         let reference = "210000000003139471430009017";
    375 
    376         let input = "21000000000313947143000901";
    377         let carry = mod10_recursive(input.as_bytes());
    378         let checksum = (10 - carry) % 10;
    379         assert_eq!(checksum, 7);
    380 
    381         assert_eq!(mod10_recursive(reference.as_bytes()), 0);
    382         assert!(subject_is_qr_bill(reference));
    383         assert!(!subject_is_qr_bill(input));
    384         assert!(!subject_is_qr_bill(""));
    385         assert!(!subject_is_qr_bill("210000000003139471430009019"));
    386         assert!(!subject_is_qr_bill("21000000000313947143000901A"));
    387 
    388         let key = "4MZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0VPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0";
    389         let key = EddsaPublicKey::from_str(key).unwrap();
    390         assert_eq!(
    391             subject_fmt_qr_bill(key.as_ref()),
    392             "442862674560948379842733643"
    393         );
    394     }
    395 
    396     #[test]
    397     fn quality() {
    398         assert_eq!(
    399             Base32Quality::measure("4MZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0VPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0"),
    400             Base32Quality::UpperStandard
    401         );
    402         assert_eq!(
    403             Base32Quality::measure("4MZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0UPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0"),
    404             Base32Quality::Upper
    405         );
    406         assert_eq!(
    407             Base32Quality::measure("4mZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0VPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0"),
    408             Base32Quality::Standard
    409         );
    410         assert_eq!(
    411             Base32Quality::measure("4mZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0UPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0"),
    412             Base32Quality::Mixed
    413         );
    414     }
    415 
    416     #[test]
    417     /** Test parsing logic */
    418     fn incoming_parse() {
    419         let key = "4MZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0VPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0";
    420         let other = "00Q979QSMJ29S7BJT3DDAVC5A0DR5Z05B7N0QT1RCBQ8FXJPZ6RG";
    421 
    422         // Common checks
    423         for ty in [IncomingType::reserve, IncomingType::kyc, IncomingType::map] {
    424             let prefix = match ty {
    425                 IncomingType::reserve => "",
    426                 IncomingType::kyc => "KYC",
    427                 IncomingType::map => "MAP",
    428             };
    429             let standard = &format!("{prefix}{key}");
    430             let (standard_l, standard_r) = standard.split_at(standard.len() / 2);
    431             let mixed = &format!("{prefix}4mzt6RS3rvb3b0e2rdmyw0yra3y0vphyv0cyde6xbb0ympfxceg0");
    432             let (mixed_l, mixed_r) = mixed.split_at(mixed.len() / 2);
    433             let other_standard = &format!("{prefix}{other}");
    434             let other_mixed =
    435                 &format!("{prefix}TEGY6d9mh9pgwvwpgs0z0095z854xegfy7jj202yd0esp8p0za60");
    436             let key = EddsaPublicKey::from_str(key).unwrap();
    437             let result = Ok(IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey { ty, key }));
    438 
    439             // Check succeed if standard or mixed
    440             for case in [standard, mixed] {
    441                 for test in [
    442                     format!("noise {case} noise"),
    443                     format!("{case} noise to the right"),
    444                     format!("noise to the left {case}"),
    445                     format!("    {case}     "),
    446                     format!("noise\n{case}\nnoise"),
    447                     format!("Test+{case}"),
    448                 ] {
    449                     assert_eq!(parse_incoming_unstructured(&test), result);
    450                 }
    451             }
    452 
    453             // Check succeed if standard or mixed and split
    454             for (l, r) in [(standard_l, standard_r), (mixed_l, mixed_r)] {
    455                 for case in [
    456                     format!("left {l}{r} right"),
    457                     format!("left {l} {r} right"),
    458                     format!("left {l}-{r} right"),
    459                     format!("left {l}+{r} right"),
    460                     format!("left {l}\n{r} right"),
    461                     format!("left {l}-+\n{r} right"),
    462                     format!("left {l} - {r} right"),
    463                     format!("left {l} + {r} right"),
    464                     format!("left {l} \n {r} right"),
    465                     format!("left {l} - + \n {r} right"),
    466                 ] {
    467                     assert_eq!(parse_incoming_unstructured(&case), result);
    468                 }
    469             }
    470 
    471             // Check concat parts
    472             for chunk_size in 1..standard.len() {
    473                 let chunked: String = standard
    474                     .as_bytes()
    475                     .chunks(chunk_size)
    476                     .flat_map(|c| [std::str::from_utf8(c).unwrap(), " "])
    477                     .collect();
    478                 for case in [chunked.clone(), format!("left {chunked} right")] {
    479                     assert_eq!(parse_incoming_unstructured(&case), result);
    480                 }
    481             }
    482 
    483             // Check failed when multiple key
    484             for case in [
    485                 format!("{standard} {other_standard}"),
    486                 format!("{mixed} {other_mixed}"),
    487             ] {
    488                 assert_eq!(
    489                     parse_incoming_unstructured(&case),
    490                     Err(IncomingSubjectErr::Ambiguous)
    491                 );
    492             }
    493 
    494             // Check accept redundant key
    495             for case in [
    496                 format!("{standard} {standard} {mixed} {mixed}"), // Accept redundant key
    497                 format!("{standard} {other_mixed}"),              // Prefer high quality
    498             ] {
    499                 assert_eq!(parse_incoming_unstructured(&case), result);
    500             }
    501 
    502             // Check prefer prefixed over simple ones
    503             for case in [
    504                 format!("{standard_l}-{standard_r} {mixed_l}-{mixed_r}"),
    505                 format!("{mixed_l}-{mixed_r} {standard_l}-{standard_r}"),
    506             ] {
    507                 let res = parse_incoming_unstructured(&case);
    508                 if !(ty == IncomingType::reserve
    509                     && matches!(res, Err(IncomingSubjectErr::Ambiguous)))
    510                 {
    511                     assert_eq!(res, result);
    512                 }
    513             }
    514 
    515             // Check failure if malformed or missing
    516             for case in [
    517                 "does not contain any reserve", // Check fail if none
    518                 &standard[1..],                 // Check fail if missing char
    519                                                 // "2MZT6RS3RVB3B0E2RDMYW0YRA3Y0VPHYV0CYDE6XBB0YMPFXCEG0", // Check fail if not a valid key TODO aws-lc does not check
    520             ] {
    521                 assert_eq!(
    522                     parse_incoming_unstructured(case),
    523                     Err(IncomingSubjectErr::Missing)
    524                 );
    525             }
    526 
    527             if ty == IncomingType::kyc || ty == IncomingType::map {
    528                 // Prefer prefixed over unprefixed
    529                 for case in [format!("{other} {standard}"), format!("{other} {mixed}")] {
    530                     assert_eq!(parse_incoming_unstructured(&case), result);
    531                 }
    532             }
    533         }
    534     }
    535 
    536     #[test]
    537     /** Test parsing logic using real cases */
    538     fn real() {
    539         // Good reserve case
    540         for (subject, key) in [
    541             (
    542                 "Taler TEGY6d9mh9pgwvwpgs0z0095z854xegfy7j j202yd0esp8p0za60",
    543                 "TEGY6d9mh9pgwvwpgs0z0095z854xegfy7jj202yd0esp8p0za60",
    544             ),
    545             (
    546                 "00Q979QSMJ29S7BJT3DDAVC5A0DR5Z05B7N 0QT1RCBQ8FXJPZ6RG",
    547                 "00Q979QSMJ29S7BJT3DDAVC5A0DR5Z05B7N0QT1RCBQ8FXJPZ6RG",
    548             ),
    549             (
    550                 "Taler NDDCAM9XN4HJZFTBD8V6FNE2FJE8G Y734PJ5AGQMY06C8D4HB3Z0",
    551                 "NDDCAM9XN4HJZFTBD8V6FNE2FJE8GY734PJ5AGQMY06C8D4HB3Z0",
    552             ),
    553             (
    554                 "KYCVEEXTBXBEMCS5R64C24GFNQVWBN5R2F9QSQ7PN8QXAP1NG4NG",
    555                 "KYCVEEXTBXBEMCS5R64C24GFNQVWBN5R2F9QSQ7PN8QXAP1NG4NG",
    556             ),
    557         ] {
    558             assert_eq!(
    559                 Ok(IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey::reserve(
    560                     EddsaPublicKey::from_str(key).unwrap(),
    561                 ))),
    562                 parse_incoming_unstructured(subject)
    563             )
    564         }
    565         // Good kyc case
    566         for (subject, key) in [(
    567             "KYC JW398X85FWPKKMS0EYB6TQ1799RMY5DDXTZ FPW4YC3WJ2DWSJT70",
    568             "JW398X85FWPKKMS0EYB6TQ1799RMY5DDXTZFPW4YC3WJ2DWSJT70",
    569         )] {
    570             assert_eq!(
    571                 Ok(IncomingSubject::Key(IncomingKey::kyc(
    572                     EddsaPublicKey::from_str(key).unwrap(),
    573                 ))),
    574                 parse_incoming_unstructured(subject)
    575             )
    576         }
    577     }
    578 
    579     #[test]
    580     fn outgoing() {
    581         let wtid = ShortHashCode::rand();
    582 
    583         // Without metadata
    584         let subject = format!("{wtid} http://exchange.example.com/");
    585         let parsed = parse_outgoing(&subject).unwrap();
    586         assert_eq!(
    587             parsed,
    588             OutgoingSubject {
    589                 wtid,
    590                 exchange_base_url: url("http://exchange.example.com/"),
    591                 metadata: None
    592             }
    593         );
    594         assert_eq!(
    595             subject,
    596             fmt_out_subject(
    597                 &parsed.wtid,
    598                 &parsed.exchange_base_url,
    599                 parsed.metadata.as_deref()
    600             )
    601         );
    602 
    603         // With metadata
    604         let subject = format!("Accounting:id.4 {wtid} http://exchange.example.com/");
    605         let parsed = parse_outgoing(&subject).unwrap();
    606         assert_eq!(
    607             parsed,
    608             OutgoingSubject {
    609                 wtid,
    610                 exchange_base_url: url("http://exchange.example.com/"),
    611                 metadata: Some("Accounting:id.4".into())
    612             }
    613         );
    614         assert_eq!(
    615             subject,
    616             fmt_out_subject(
    617                 &parsed.wtid,
    618                 &parsed.exchange_base_url,
    619                 parsed.metadata.as_deref()
    620             )
    621         );
    622     }
    623 }